Why did the job margin fall? Separate price, quantity and labour variances

A worked construction example separating material price changes, excess consumption and extra labour hours without double counting.

Enfin editorial team4 minute read

A lower job margin does not explain what went wrong. Separate the difference between estimate and actual cost into material prices, material quantities, labour hours and other costs. That gives you a specific estimating decision instead of a blanket increase on every future quotation.

This method is for a Belgian contractor reviewing a completed work package. The figures are illustrative, exclude VAT and are not industry benchmarks. The resulting contribution is not automatically accounting profit: both sides must include the same categories of cost.

Establish a comparable scope

Do not compare an estimate for one hundred square metres with the cost of delivering one hundred and twenty. Separate approved additional work and identify the original quotation version. Preserve the original supplier prices too. Replacing them with today’s price list would erase part of the variance you are trying to explain.

Buildwise’s guidance on site follow-up and costing stresses reliable records of hours, materials, equipment and subcontractors. A missing supplier invoice is therefore an unknown cost, not evidence that the job incurred no expense.

Work through an example that balances

A work package sells for € 10,000. Its estimate includes one hundred material units at € 30, eighty labour hours at an internal cost of € 40 and € 800 of other costs. Estimated cost is € 7,000, leaving a contribution of € 3,000: 30% of the selling price.

Actual delivery uses 110 units at € 33, 92 hours at the same € 40 internal rate and € 900 of other costs. Actual cost is € 3,630 + € 3,680 + € 900 = € 8,210. With unchanged revenue, contribution falls to € 1,790, or 17.9%. The difference to explain is € 1,210.

  • Material price variance: 110 × (€ 33 − € 30) = € 330.
  • Material quantity variance: (110 − 100) × € 30 = € 300.
  • Labour hours variance: (92 − 80) × € 40 = € 480.
  • Other costs: € 900 − € 800 = € 100.

These figures add to exactly € 1,210. This convention measures the price effect using actual quantity and the quantity effect using the estimated price. Use one convention consistently. Mixing methods can count the combined price-and-quantity effect twice.

Investigate the explanation behind each amount

The € 330 may come from an expired price list, a smaller pack size or an urgent order. The € 300 may represent cutting waste, an incorrect measurement, damaged goods or reusable material still in stock. Material moved to another job should not silently remain charged as consumption on this one.

The twelve extra hours also need context. Separate productive work, travel, waiting, rework and approved additions where your records allow it. Waiting for site access calls for a different response from consistently underestimating installation time. Do not use a cost variance to judge an employee without understanding the working conditions.

Assign one practical correction to each cause

Record the evidence, cause, owner and next action for every meaningful variance. An outdated purchase price needs a new source date. An unrealistic labour allowance needs a revised productivity assumption. Unclear scope needs better quotation wording. A one-off breakage does not automatically justify a permanent uplift across every quote.

Check what is already included in the internal hourly rate. Avoid charging the same vehicle costs or overhead twice. If important costs remain unavailable, label the result provisional and identify what must arrive before the review can close.

Feed the result into the next estimate

Keep the old assumption, the revised assumption and the job that supports the change. Test the revision on a comparable project before applying it everywhere. This calculation complements the broader construction job costing guide.

To assess your own process, explore Enfin with an anonymised estimate, time record and materials list. In a demonstration, ask how the original estimate, changes and missing costs remain visible. A useful costing process should let you explain the number, not merely display it.

All articles